Category: Blog

  • “Everybody has a plan until they get punched in the mouth.”

    “Everybody has a plan until they get punched in the mouth.”

    That’s what former world champion boxer Mike Tyson said in response to a reporter who wanted to know if he was worried about opponent Evander Holyfield’s strategy.

    “What’s do you think will happen?” he was asked.

    “[My opponent’s]  going to move, he’s going to dance. He’s going to do this, do that.’ said Tyson. “I’ve got a plan. Everybody has a plan… until they get hit. Then… they stop in fear and freeze.”

    Crises are administrative gut punches, no matter how big or small the inciting incident — whether on the global scale of COVID-19 or raw chicken in the cafeteria. Overnight, situations quickly turn into emergencies.

    As chief spokesperson — and the senior-most person on whose desk the communications buck comes to a screeching halt — I expect the unexpected every day. It goes with the territory. I know that even when the trains are humming along, they could be derailed at any moment, regardless of how many months we have spent hashing out a fail-safe crisis plan, how many useless table-top exercises we’ve done, or how good the plan looks on paper.

    Everyone has a plan until a crisis hits and then it goes out the window.

    And right now, everything is in emergency mode.

    According to a recent article in the Harvard Business Review, 5 Principles to Guide Adaptive Leadership, “… the Covid-19 pandemic is constantly evolving, with leaders facing unpredictability, imperfect information, multiple unknowns, and the need to identify responses quickly — all while recognizing the multi-dimensional (health-related, economic, social, political, cultural) nature of the crisis.”

    There is no playbook for this or any other raging-out-of-control issue that suddenly envelops an institution; no cookie-cutter, off the shelf, one-size-fits-all solution, especially now. As one VP of Enrollment, a member of his university’s executive team, said to me recently, “we’re all just making this up as we go along.”

    I (grudgingly) accept that I, as chief communicator, won’t get it completely right, because there is no right. But here are a few things I keep front and center when I find myself unexpectedly in the middle of the ring:

    1. To Thine Own Self Be True
      You know what you’re good at and what you’re not. Reckon with your blind spots and assess what you need to do accordingly.  
    2. Tap Into Your Inner Circle
      Build a small group of trusted advisers who fill in those blind spots — who’ll tell you what they think and on whose judgement you can invariably rely.
    3. It Really Does Take a Village
      No one can operate in a vacuum and, as a leader, you have to move quickly and decisively. Recognize that not everyone will see things the way you do, and will have their own strong opinions about what needs to be done. Understand that everyone handles information differently, and really useful feedback often comes from far-flung and unexpected places.
    4. Keep Your Ear to the Ground
      Listen and listen hard to your social media channels, to the intel and real time data that is there for the taking. You’ll know what messages are getting through, which are not, and where the pain points are.
    5. All of Us Fly by the Seat of Our Pants
      Our work in marketing, absent crises, would be very dull indeed. There’s something about jumping out of a plane without a safety net when the stakes are sky high that is both terrifying and exhilarating. It’s a moment when we’re forced to act — for better or worse — whether we want to or not. 

    In the end, the adversity of crises does not define us, but how we deal with them does.

  • Who Needs a Chief Marketing Officer Anyway?

    Who Needs a Chief Marketing Officer Anyway?

    “Marketing is a nice to have, not a must have.”

    “It’s nothing more than spin.”

    “We got along just fine without it…”

    “The website is fine the way it is.”

    “It taints the academic purity of what we do.” 

    Sound familiar?

    These are actual quotes, by the way. Over the many years that I’ve been at this game, I’ve heard all of these out-of-hand dismissals — and countless other variations on the same theme — from scores of deans and senior higher ed leaders who are intent on downplaying the role of marketing in higher education.

    At Harvard, as well as many of the colleges and universities I’ve worked for, we called it the “M” word. And still do. Seriously.

    There remains only a grudging acceptance of the need to maintain a strategic marketing function, to expand a once strictly service orientation into a crucial function that drives admissions, recruitment, and fundraising.

    And the pandemic has only made marketing matters worse. As the longest spring and summer in recent memory now reels into an unimaginable fall, marketing budgets are getting hammered, returning marketing teams to the days of yesteryear, back to print-on-demand services and away from integrated marketing strategy. According to recent Gartner research, a full 45% of CMOs say COVID-19 has driven their institutions to significantly reduce (or eliminate) their 2020 marketing budgets.

    If ever there was a time for CMOs to rise to the occasion, it is now.

    And here are just a few reasons why…

    1. That Leadership Thing: We are the face of integrated marketing and communication initiatives. 
    2. Charting the Course: We steer the marketing, communications, and branding strategy. 
    3. Managing the Newsroom: We are the place where the buck stops on all things editorial — publications, websites, social media, advertising, media relations, and anything else that even remotely falls into this category.
    4. Putting Out Fires: We act as the first (and last) line of defense when crises and issues flare. 
    5. Running the In-House, On Demand Ad Agency: Enough said. 
    6. Oh So Proudly Waving the Marketing Flag: We know with certainty that good marketing lifts all boats.  
    7. (Wo)Manning the Social Media Barricades: We keep the powerful engines of social media roaring. 
    8. Flying the Plane: We pilot a diverse team of web producers, graphic designers, project managers, marketing and editorial writers, media specialists and videographers.
    9. Standing and (Always) Delivering: We champion the institutional story; honing the narrative, asserting the value proposition and articulating the benefit promise — saying it, saying it, and yes, saying it again. 

    Now is not the time for the faint of heart.

    But, then again, who needs a CMO, anyway?

  • Just Do It, As the Saying Goes

    Just Do It, As the Saying Goes

    “I’m a terrible writer” people say apologetically to me, as if not being able to craft a press release, a social media post, a report, or even an email — is a major character flaw.

    Most people I know would rather have a root canal.

    It’s not always easy for me, either. And I’m in the business of writing, of finding the right words, the right tone, and the right way for what other people want to say. But I’ve learned over many years that effective, persuasive writing can be a daunting task. 

    Here’s some things that may help:

    Make the Blank Doc Your Friend

    The historian Daniel Boorstin once said that “writing is a process of discovery.” I never produce my best stuff right out of the gate. Where I begin is rarely where I end up. I use a system of rapid jotting — a fast, uncensored bulleted list of everything I think I might want to convey. It gets everything out of my head and onto the page. I’m always surprised by what I uncover.

    Rise to the Occasion

    My good friend Pete Sena, founder and chief creative officer at Digital Surgeons, a global brand consultancy, suggests taking the process of discovery one step further: stand up and just say it. I often do this when I’m really stuck. I’ve discovered Loom, a free audio and video app that records what you say and sends you a transcript. Do this standing up, as if you’re talking to a colleague and let it rip. You’ll be amazed at how the points you want to make suddenly crystallize.

    (Out)Loud + Proud

    Michael Katz, founder of Blue Penguin Development, who practically invented the e-newsletter and who has helped legions of small business owners communicate effectively, advises his clients to always read their final draftsaloud. Proofreading will not catch all the pesky things — double commas, repeated words, typos you didn’t see the first five times you read it through. 

    Progress Over Perfection

    That I didn’t need to be a Pulitzer prize-winning writer every time I sat down in front of my computer was hard for me to accept. We all want praise and adulation for our work. We want to be respected for our ideas and how we convey them. But striving for perfection in anything, especially how we write, is a zero-sum game. I’ve found that if perfection is what I’m aiming for, I’m dead on arrival. Instead, I allow myself the luxury of being “good enough” which makes me infinitely more productive and which turns the dread of all that white space into one that I now welcome.

    Can’t get past the first sentence? I can help. Email me.

  • Telling The Truth

    Telling The Truth

    “The disruption caused by the coronavirus pandemic has prompted cobbled-together responses ranging from the absurd to the ingenious at colleges and universities struggling to continue teaching even as their students have receded into diminutive images, in dire need of haircuts, on videoconference checkerboards.”

    So sayeth The New York Times

    If you’re a senior college administrator you’re in a tough spot right now. The call for answers is deafening — parents, students, faculty, alumni, boards, and the media are demanding information. Everyone wants to know the unknowable — what will colleges and universities actually be like in the fall? 

    As leadership teams struggle to put into words the no-win scenarios available to them, Rome burns.

    Here’s a radical thought: what would happen if you were not afraid of transparency? 

    Not long ago, I worked at a prestigious liberal arts college, known for its progressive politics and campus activism. Suddenly, we found ourselves in the midst of a five day occupation of the president’s office. Students were demanding that college officials accept the demands of maintenance workers for fair wages. 

    About thirty students moved in with sleeping bags; dozens more set-up tents outside the windows. And, it coincided with Admitted Students Day where the escalating protest was in full view of hundreds of parents and prospective students touring the campus. 

    Bound by confidentiality, we could not discuss our position at the bargaining table. But what we could do was to solicit difficult questions — which is exactly what the Dean of Students did. He brought his own sleeping bag and spent those five days on the floor with students. In doing so, he slowly gained student trust by seeing them not as a problem to get rid of, but as a genuine and important part of the solution. 

    Here is some of what we wrote in a letter to the student body:

    “In keeping with our aspirations to be open and inclusive, we will and must make every attempt to shelter honest, often difficult dialogue, in and out of the classroom, if we are really to acknowledge one another.”

    That president’s letter, and the actions of the Dean, were credible. There was no attempt at sugar-coating. It was the first step towards trust, towards giving the president the benefit of the doubt. 

    During these last six months, college presidents (and the executive teams that support them) have become the Mario Cuomos of their own small city-states, governing amidst an ongoing and deafening call for answers, guidance, and scarce resources.

    In that role, your primary job is to inspire confidence and cooperation. When it comes to crisis communications, there are four things you need to keep in mind:

    1. Display calm confidence. Leaders lead.
    2. Address issues and challenges as they arise. Be as transparent as possible. 
    3. Be absolutely crystal clear. Ambiguity is not your friend.
    4. Use social media to carry on an ongoing conversation.

    What we want to see in a leader is that they’re transparent, credible and accountable.

    And while none of us can foresee or script the future, it is important to be the person who gives us the information we need; someone with a thoughtful, no-holds-barred, unvarnished approach — someone able to engender trust quickly, at a time when we need it more than ever. 

    Someone who tells the truth.

  • Leading with Empathy During a Crisis

    Leading with Empathy During a Crisis

    September 11, 2001 was my son’s first day at NYU. The phone lines were down. The city was closed. There was no way to find out if he was okay.

    In desperation, I did the only thing I could think to do — I wrote to the dean. With no expectation that she would respond, or even read it, as the horror continued to unfold. I emailed her anyway, a desperate parent begging to know what the university was doing to keep these frightened and bewildered 18-year-olds safe.

    She wrote back the next day…

    I’ve been thinking a lot about that dean’s response to me recently as colleges and universities grapple with how to communicate with increasingly anxious and uncertain parents. How do you offer both much-needed reassurance and tactical information at the same time?

    Here are five important lessons I learned from that letter and what I recommend you consider when  responding to parents  in the midst of a crisis:

    1. Respond Quickly

    The simple fact that she wrote back right away impressed me more than anything else.

    No one knew much at that point, but she took the time to reassure me that the wellbeing and safety of students was their highest priority. She probably said this in different ways to many people in the days that followed, but I felt that she was speaking directly to me.

    1. Make It Personal

    Her tone was both sympathetic and straightforward. There was no “administrative speak.” She showed empathy with me as a fellow parent. She encouraged me to stay in touch.

    1. Acknowledge Anxiety and Fear

    She didn’t try to sugarcoat the degree of distress and helplessness that we as parents, but more importantly, our students, were feeling. Instead, she made it clear that she shared in our collective apprehension.

    1. Summarize What You Do/ Do Not Know

    She promised regular updates, and outlined immediate plans for the cessation of classes and plans for academic support. We don’t have all the answers, she wrote plainly, and there is a great deal we do not know. 

    This engendered trust, a crucial component when dealing with unfolding and unpredictable events. I knew that she was giving it to me straight.

    1. “We Got This”

    We all want to know that the people we entrust our children to have the situation under control, even if they don’t.

    As crises continue to unfold, parents  want to know that you’re on top of things. Reassurance is what they are looking for, with the assertion that there are all kinds of capable people doing everything they can.

    For example, “teams of individuals are working tirelessly to determine how we can all be safe during the difficult days ahead. We are grateful to the Health Services, Campus Safety and Student Affairs teams that are working through complex scenarios with diligence and care.”

    Nearly twenty years later, it is remarkable that I can still recall what she said and the impact it had on me.

    As a leader in higher ed faced with an unexpected crisis, you’ve got the same opportunity to instill a sense of trust. No one knows what the new academic year will look like, but as long as you can lead with empathy, what you say will go a long way towards garnering the support you and your colleagues will need going forward.